Your Early Childhood Money Scripts

I have been in annual review meetings for the past few months and have had some fantastic conversations with clients about spending behaviors. You might expect a financial advisor to talk about the problems of overspending. And there are cases of that. But if you’ve been following along with me for the past few years, you know one thing that comes up a lot is chronic underspending or risk aversion. One of my favorite conversations happens when we dig into the “why” behind the spending habit. I’ve had a few of these opportunities lately.

One client told me that talking about money makes her deeply uncomfortable. She said that as a girl she would go shopping with her mother, and at the register her mother's card would be declined because her father had not paid the bill. It happened again and again, and her mother was humiliated every time. She also felt that humiliation. That client is in excellent financial shape today. In the same meeting, she asked me for the highest possible return with no risk, and described the portfolio as not really her money, something to preserve for her children while she spends as little as she can. None of that is irrational if the memory is the only evidence being weighed. It just has very little to do with her actual balance sheet. 

Another client grew up on a farm with parents who never went to college. He has climbed the career ladder and earns a high six-figure salary. For years, he and his wife bought insurance products with guaranteed floors, because a floor is what you want when you have seen the bottom. The instinct is understandable. They were also paying real money to protect against a scenario their income and savings already covered. 

A third client's father went bankrupt farming in Iowa when my client was two years old. The family moved west and lived on a fifty-dollar-a-month mortgage. He carried forward his father's optimism, handing business cards to strangers in restaurants and always finding the next thing. But he also told his child to never take a job that pays on commission. Two lessons from the same event, one that served him for a lifetime and one that narrowed his career options. 

Not every script comes from childhood. One client told me her upbringing around money was unremarkable, with no drama either way. Her late husband's family, however, was tight on small purchases while giving generously on the big ones, and he carried that forward. She recalled a memory from when she needed new clothes for work, and he thought the cost was unreasonable. Over the years, she absorbed it, and she described it to me as having become part of her spending DNA. She is still living by it now, with more than enough to increase her spending 2-3x. 

I have my own version, too. My parents, as business owners, had a lot of financial ups and downs. The business took an unfortunate turn as I was entering my teenage years. That was jarring, and it shaped how I thought about money and risk. Ask my wife, Emily, who had to put up with me during the first year of our marriage, when I was white-knuckling our budget. It took me a few years to realize I'd adopted financial beliefs that weren’t completely rational, but were shaped by my own experience. 

The question worth asking is not whether the memory is accurate. The question is whether the situation that wrote the rule is the situation you are living in now. A memory can be very persuasive, but it contains no numbers. Part of why I love planning is that the numbers bring to the surface what is objectively true about someone’s finances. It provides new evidence to weigh against the old. While some clients look at it once and relax, most need to see it a few years running, and do some personal work around their money beliefs before it sinks in. 

If you have caught yourself making a money decision that your own balance sheet does not support, spend some time questioning it. If you're a client, I’d love to talk with you about it.  

Happy Planning, 

Alex 

This blog post is not advice. Please read disclaimers. 

Next
Next

Most Stocks Are Worse Than the Market